5/17/2006

Muslims Stop Holding Your Breath.......

Hello,

I have been reading with interest the debate about Ayaan Hirsi Ali's recent fall from grace over at Pickled Politics . The post which kicks it all off argues that Ali did nothing to help Muslim women reform their communities and made it harder for them to take a stand. One commenter points out Ali did give assistance to a young Muslim woman who was being physically abused by her family, an act for which she should be commended. However I believe her adoption of an 'either or ' position regarding Islam and the rights of women has at best done nothing to help Muslim feminists and at worst may even have damaged their position by making it easier for them to be attacked as un-Islamic.

I should stress that I have no quarrel with her decision to reject Islam. Whilst I personally have no religious beliefs, I accept that other people do and believe that Ali was ultimately more concerned with promoting her personal view of Islam than supporting Muslim women. The difficulty with her position is that it is unrealistic to expect vast numbers of Muslim women to accept it. After all in rejecting Islam they would be rejecting their own sincerely held religious beliefs, and in some cases their friends and family not to mention social and cultural attachments. Rather than go over the whole Ali business again , I intend to ramble for a bit about Islam and women.

It cannot be denied that from a feminist perspective the Qu'ran contains a number of troubling passages, though I am baffled at the insistence of some that this is 'real' Islam whereas the more female friendly passages can be safely ignored. Could the hostility between the Muslim fundamentalists and the Islamaphobes be mutual projected self loathing, given that their interpretations of Islam are strikingly similar?

I take the view that if you are concerned with the rights of Muslim women rather than seeking opportunities to attack Islam, then your time would be better spent educating Muslim women about their religious rights than telling them to give up their religion. If you claim you are not Islamophobic but are critical of Islam as it is currently practised, then give all these women your support. Oh and of course I will expect your full support of my western feminist goals. Otherwise I might get the wrong idea and think you're going in for all that ' uncivilised barbarians mistreating their bitches' stuff and I'd doubt your commitment to the ladies cause.

To illustrate what I mean by 'religious rights' let me cite a couple of examples. Muslim women are entitled to a pre-nup just like Hollywood stars. In fact they've been at it for years. Zeinab Al Ghazali was born in 1918 and discarded one husband for breaching his marriage contract before remarrying on better terms for a second time. The grounds of divorce were that he 'took up all of my time and kept me from my mission'. Zeinab was a member of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood, which I think makes her a prime example of what I am getting at when I reject what I have termed the 'either or' option above. I would also suggest that women's rights would be best served by ensuring that all Muslim women are aware of their Allah given right to negotiate the terms of their marriage contract and have the confidence to assert their rights in this area.

A more romantic version of independent life for Muslim women comes in the form of a Sufi mystic and poet Rabiah al- Adawiyyah. She lived alone, was celibate, vegetarian and lived a life devoted to prayer and mediation. A Sufi woman who rejects wealth and sexual love because there was no room in her heart for anyone but Allah, cannot properly be considered un-Islamic unless one is more concerned with sectarian in-fighting than Allah.

It is also worth noting that women are forbidden to cover their face when on pilgrimage to Mecca. Why is it un-Islamic to behave as well as if one is on Hajj at all times? I have no problem with women covering up in the name of Islam if they choose to, though I confess I'm slightly puzzled why baring all is regarded as liberating in western culture. That said, I must admit I do enjoy the sight of a nudie lady.

Muslim law is founded on three components the Qu'ran, the Hadith and the 'ulama' . Anyone regardless of gender can become a member of the ulama (people with an in depth knowledge of Islamic law). This feminist suggests that it is high time the ulama included a few women and suggests it is up to men to come up with reasons why they cannot join. At the same time they might also wish to explain why their wives cannot enjoy the similar status to the prophet Muhammed's wives Khadijah (businesswoman) and Ai'isha ("take half your religion from this one") unless they are suggesting that Mohammed couldn't control his women in which case I'll step aside and watch them talk their way out of that one. Neither the Qu'ran or the Hadith can be reformed but the ulama can. I vote we stop bashing Islam and start supporting women. After all as Mohammed stated in answer to the question 'Whom should I honour most? 'Your mother, Your mother, Your mother' and then your father.

You may wonder why I'm sticking my beak in so I shall explain:
1. I am a feminist.
2. I am a curtain twitcher
3. This was all I could think of to write about.

Cheerio

12 comments:

poor_khalid said...

A well-reasoned and insightful post. Much better than the most of the irrational anti-Islamic vitriol that I've been reading lately. It's too bad you're not a Muslim, we could all benefit from your wisdom.

ali said...

it's not too late to convert sister :)

Clairwil said...

That's very kind of you 'poor khalid'.
There is some utterly terrifying stuff about Islam flying about the internet at the moment. From reading most of it I get the impression that some people just enjoy the hysteria.

Clairwil said...

Sorry Ali, I didn't see you sneak in there. Convert? Stranger things have happened.

Billy said...

Excellent post! Wow...

Clairwil said...

Thank-you Billy.
However a far wiser man than I has spotted a problem with it. See the following comment by justforfun here: http://www.pickledpolitics.com/archives/537.

"A donkey carrying books is not literate"

Sadly justforfun doesn't appear to have a blog of his own. So we'll never know how it should be done.

matt lobster said...

Why would a donkey be carrying books if he didn't intend to read them?

Clairwil said...

You'd best ask justforfun. He's the intellectual.

mirax said...

Your such an IMHO bitch sucking up to the boys. Do you actually think any of that is relevant or interesting to any women. I have so many issues with you, the endorsement of this post and your views I dont know where to start.

miraxx@gmail.com said...

I just idly googling my handle when I came across this. I am a regular on Pickled Politics and I was quite involved in the discussion there at the time. I never came to your blog to post that vile message, so please know it was NOT me. I'd never call another woman a bitch, in fact I took exception to AHA being insulted such on the very first post of the thread on her at PP.

I am disappointed that someone who lurks or posts misused my id in such a way.


Mirax

liwo said...

香港女星寫真,a片分享,美女色情裸體,台灣kiss情色貼圖,美腿圖,正妹,日本情色網,情色卡通下載,免費下載的做愛照片,線上a片免費看,tube影片,情色成人,ro 私服論壇,色情網,aaa片免費看短片分享區,日本人妻熟女自拍貼圖,蕃薯論壇,台灣網友自拍貼照,嘟嘟成人網,狂插漂亮美眉,8591論壇,女同志聊天室,人妻俱樂部網站,背包客棧論壇,成人性感內衣,看美女脫光光,黑澀會美眉無名,色咪咪貼影片,無碼a片,aa片免費看,免費線上觀看a片,做愛的圖片,色情漫畫,性感卡通美女圖片,香港a片,自拍,情色圖書館,plus 28 論壇,1007視訊,熟女自拍照,苗栗人聊天室,黑澀會美眉即時通,jp成人,色情,aaaaa片俱樂部,情侶歡愉用品,

okav成人影院,網友裸體自拍,交友ukiss,娘家影片,a片免費,黑澀會美眉即時通,人妻性交俱樂部,聊天室尋夢園,18禁,情色性感美女圖片,美女短片免費試看,3級女星寫真,情色短片論壇,摯愛中年聊天室,美腿貼圖,影音聊天,聊天室找一夜,g世代論壇,免費線上影片,淫蕩少女,火辣美眉自拍寫真貼圖,內衣寫真秀,美少女自拍,aa片免費看影片,麗的情色,gogo2sex,aooyy 成人玩具,台灣成人網,素人自拍,

fgeegf said...

sogo情色網,小魔女免費影片,9k躺伯虎聊天室,只有貼圖區,網路美女,a片小遊戲,比基尼辣妹影片,視訊交友90739,免費色情影片,星光情色討論版,18禁地戀愛遊戲,廁所偷拍,18禁,台灣kiss情色文學,線上看,飯島愛影片觀看,免費線上影片,美腿論壇,聊天室找一夜,情色自拍,影音日誌,自拍片,寫真女郎攝影網,網愛聊天室,情色文學網,av女優dvd,dudu 嘟嘟貼圖區,比基尼辣妹影片,視訊聊天室,自拍照片,成人論壇,模特兒寫真,a片dvd,情色偷拍,美女遊戲,666 貼圖區,成人短片,線上觀看a片,免費a片線上看,080 聊天室,情色交友,女生自衛影片,男男貼圖區,免費線上觀看a片,模特兒,家庭教師影片,情色貼片,美女貼圖片區,免費aa片試看,成人貼圖區,網際論壇,

線上直播a片,免費a圖a片,080 聊天室,av視訊,情色交友,模特兒,自拍影片,真實自拍,嘟嘟情色,視訊,免費視訊聊天室,壞朋友論壇fliendo,成人a片,美女交友,383v live實境影音秀,嘟嘟貼圖,花王自拍,飯島愛寫真集,微風寫真網,忘年之交聊天室,爽翻天成人用品,正妹百人斬,383影音live秀,美女做愛,天天情色,免費視訊聊天室,vlog電眼美女,聊天室080,情色貼片,無碼女優,showlive影音聊天網,日本女優,都都成人站,視訊會議,080 苗栗人聊天室,洪爺情色網,北部人聊天室,一葉晴貼圖區,色遊戲,同志影片,aaaa片俱樂部,免費影片線上直播,ut男同志聊天室,貼影片,免費a片下載,歐美模特兒寫真,百分百成人圖片,ut 女同聊天室,夫妻自拍,